SUNY Geneseo Department of Mathematics

The Formal Definition of Limit, Part 2

Wednesday, February 13

Math 221 03
Spring 2019
Prof. Doug Baldwin

Return to Course Outline

Previous Lecture

SI Session

This afternoon, 3:00 PM, in Bailey.

Questions?

Proving Limits

Example

... from last time.

Prove that limx→3 2x - 1 = 5

Strategy:

  1. Give a way of finding δ from ε
  2. Show that the δ you find really works, i.e., keeps 2x - 1 within ε of 5

Graph of 2x - 1 with epsilon interval around y = 5 and delta interval around x = 3

For the first step, start with | f(x) - L | being less than ε, and see if you can get from there to something that looks like δ.

Simplify 2x-1-5 to 2x-6, then divide everything by 2 to suggest delta = epsilon/2

The for the second step, work from this δ forward until you confirm that |f(x) - L| is less than ε.

From abs(x-3) less than epsilon/2, multiply by 2, distribute it into abs(x-3), and write -6 as -1 - 5.

In this proof, the second step was basically the first one done backwards. Does this always happen? No, it’s mostly a consequence of the function in question being linear (i.e., its graph is a straight line). The book has an example of a limit of x2 as x approaches 2 where the derivation of δ is more intuitive, and its result is that δ is the smallest of 2 possibilities. As a result, showing that x values within this δ of 2 produce y values within ε of 4 still involves ideas from the derivation of δ, but in ways that feel less like just doing that derivation in reverse.

Another Proof

Prove the limit law limx→a c = c where a and c are any constants.

Someone did essentially this in the limit game, with limx→1 3. The key realization was that no matter what tolerance you’re offered, 3 is always 3, it never varies. In a little more general form...

No matter what interval around the line y = c you pick, any x value keeps f(x) = c in that interval

This sort of use is the real value of the formal definition. It’s too awkward to use to find specific limits, but it justifies the rules that make those specific limits easy to find.

Key Point

Limit laws (and other methods for reasoning about limits) all have reasons.

Next

Remember our discussion of calculating instantaneous speed from distance traveled.

Speed is change in distance over change in time, calculated over small interval

Now that you know about limits, how would they help you solve this problem exactly?

Read section 3.1 about derivatives.

Next Lecture